One of the perfect things.

The Critics Circle

Three Perfect Things

Or Two Plus One

William Russell

Published: 21/08/2011

The Jermyn Street theatre is the jewel in the crown of London’s intimate
theatres – it even has seats that are comfortable – well more comfortable than
any of the others. Situated just off Piccadilly it is home to small scale plays
and intimate musical shows and the one which has just finished a week showcase
is among the best of the year. Compilation shows based on the songs of Noel
Coward are two a penny – Cowardy Custard spawned endless imitations but Adrian
Fisher and Stuart Barham have come up with a splendid variation on a theme –
their show, The Two Most Perfect Things, is about the monarchs of all they surveyed
in the London theatre for some thirty years – Noel Coward and Ivor Novello.

  Coward’s reputation today rests on his plays – his musicals are by and large forgotten although his cabaret songs are remembered. But Novello is a different matter. His musicals were lavish and very much of their time. A major revival
is probably financially impossible in the commercial theatre because the shows
were invariably very lavish, and, apart from anything else, the Ruritanian plots
are often pretty dreadful. He is virtually forgotten. The songs are another
matter, however. He was a brilliant theatre composer – no one hit wonder
musicals from him.

With The Two Most Perfect Things Fisher and Barham have devised a near perfect evening during
which they trace the parallel careers of the two men. There is little about
their private lives, but it is the work that matters, although at times they
skate a little too lightly over  some of their theatrical past. Post war Britain
saw Novello’s greatest success, King’s Rhapsody, and his small scale Gay’s the
Word, also a hit. But they ignore Coward’s less successful West End shows and
failing to mention that he did re-open Drury Lane with Pacific which starred
Mary Martin, one of Broadway’s great ladies, is really unfair – it was a flawed
show, it was not in the Oklahoma mould, but it has some good songs, as do some
of the others – The Girl Who Came to Supper for one which, in this Rattigan
year, might have produced a song for them to use. They also, although they
mention both men wrote for a series of revues in the thirties, have not really
given any examples of Novello’s ability to write a point number other than Her
Mother Came Too, and even if the thirties revue songs in the archives do not
stand the test of time they could have done Primrose from The Dancing Years
which is short, tuneful and funny. It might also have been nice to have had a
song from Lily of the Valley, the last show Novello wrote for the leading lady soprano
of the time, Lizbeth Webb. But one quibbles really because the songs that are
included are so good and the cast  - Fisher, Barham – at the piano -  Charles
Howell, Margaret Preece and Isabelloe Roeland are impeccable.

All too often small theatre shows are cast with young persons fresh from drama school,  but these are all seasoned performers, however,  and musicians of some standing who do full justice to their material.  Preece is gloriously
funny, Roeland sings the great Novello ballads perfectly, as does Howell, while Fisher, who does not remotely resemble the Master, performs his material to perfection. This gem of a show demonstrates beyond any doubt that there was
a West End musical life before Andrew Lloyd Webber – something many people do not know.

 Maybe they could have included Coward’s greatest lyric,  arguably his words for Porter’s Lets Do It and are even  better than those penned by the great Cole, but that would have moved dangerously close to Cowardy Custard territory. The show's title is Coward’s description of the pair –although there is a sting in the tail.

It has been most handsomely staged by Tim Reed and deserves to have a future out there in
the larger world.


Enquiries about the Critics' Circle should be made to the Hon Gen Sec Rick Jones by email or telephone 020 8698 2460.