Photo © Richard Hubert Smith

Any opera house’s first Parsifal should be an occasion; for the hallowed setting of Glyndebourne, maybe doubly so. This was also director Jetske Mijnssen’s Glyndebourne debut; one of a plethora of house debuts: the singers taking Parsifal, Kundry and Klingsor also appeared for the first time. 

Wagner’s Parsifal asks questions so vast they seem to shake the very foundations of our being. In calling his last (greatest?) work a ‘Bühnenweihfesspiel’ – usually translated as ‘a festival of consecration in the theatre,’ while Glyndebourne prefers ‘festival play for the consecration of a stage’ – Wagner implies a melding not only of words, music and theatre but also a spiritual act that transcends all three and takes us at least in the direction of the Divine. In Parsifal, or at least in the libretto, Christian ideas – arguably those of a Christianity’s esoteric arms, such as Rosicrucianism – meet the reincarnations and Nirvana of Buddhism (Klingsor explicitly lists Kundry’s prior incarnations a one point in the second act). 

When it comes to the director, Jetske Mijnssen, I wonder if the idea of human-centric spirituality (religiosity, perhaps) appeals to her? My previous experience of Mijnssen was in Strasbourg at Opéra national du Rhin in 2019, when she staged Legrenzi’s soap opera for the gods and goddesses, Il divisione del mondo (with Les Talens Lyriques and Christophe Rousset). It was a sort of semi-Divine Upstairs Downstairs with Divinities prey to all sorts of human urges. For Parsifal, we are in a dwelling set in Wagner’s own time; the set remains throughout; cleverly, though, scenes in Gurnemanz’s long narrations are acted out in more idyllic sets-within-sets. We also see (though obviously not hear) Herzeleide, Parsifal’s mother, as part of the back story. 

Perhaps ‘cleverness’’ is the production’s downfall. The sect is a definably Christian one: Gurnemanz and others don the robes of Christianist ritual. Could one message be that Christianity itself has, like the Grail Order, atrophied? And that it needs a Parsifal-like fresh redeemer figure? And who is the mysterious Kundry in this set-up? Initially, she is a servant: less wild woman, more harried downstairs helper. An outsider still, though; so, in this context the pull between Kundry and Parsifal is understandable, two people at the fringes of an established order (or is that Order?). We see pre-echoes of the second act seduction in the first act: too early? Perhaps not: Mijnssen could be riffing on Gurnemanz’s famous equating of time and space immediately prior to the act I Transformation Music (‘Du siehst, mein Sohn / zum Raum wird hie die Zeit’)?. Maybe. 

The oppressiveness of the set courtesy of Ben Baur, underlined by Fabrice Kebour’s lighting, plus Mijnssen’s turning away from Spiritual enlightenment  to domestic drama, of fraternal conflict (Amfortas and Klingsor, with Kundry in the middle), of households invaded, seems to be influenced by Ibsen. This much is explicitly stated in the accompanying booklet with its bouquet of fabulously-written essays. And yet one figure not mentioned at all as an influence, yet surely there is the Danish artist Vilhelm Hammershøi (1864-1916), whose muted enigmas of paintings, dark, full of question marks –  figures often turned away from the viewer – seem to reincarnate in this ancient Grail tale. 

The production’s obviously religious pageantry certainly implies a collective primed for Parsifal’s disruption.; their rituals palpably do not work There are other collectives, too: multiple versions of characters, the non-singing ones played by actors: there is, for example, Young Kundry (Cecilia Young), Old Kundry (Rose Sanders), Young Amfortas (Cameron Fuller), and Old Amfortas (Ralf Higgins), Young Klingsor (Hugo Dunkley) and Old Klingsor (Neil Paterson), plus Herzeleide (Lucy Burns). The greatest expansion, though is Kundry: the Flower Maidens (‘Blümenmädchen’) are all Kundrys, an interesting sleight. There is more than a hint of the Matrix films about all of this. 

As to the spear/dagger, in turn this is alchemically morphed into another: Klingsor becomes returnee (he is very present, if silently, in the final act). 

Before turning to the singing, it is the orchestra that deserves praise eternal lavished upon it. The LPO plays its collective heart out for Robin Ticciati, be it unfeasibly angular and fast string passages (immediately prior to Kundry’s act II ‘Lachte,’ for example – we will return to that), to creamy brass absolutely together (and you could count split notes in the entiire evening easily on the fingers of one hand). The LPO was like plastic in in Ticciati’s hands; and he had the overview of the piece perfectly, its two ritualisic pillars of acts I and III containing the remarkable concision of the second act. On the micro-Leitmotivic level, too, little seemed to escape Ticciati’s radar: a case in point might be Kundry’s question to Parsifal in the second act, what bought him here to Klingsor’s realm if not the will to know (‘die Kunde Wunsch’)?; the answer rests not in Parsifal’s part, but in the horn’s quoting of the opening of the Spear motif, an ascent of just four notes and yet of huge import, and impeccably done here. We felt the dramatic tension even as Parsifal himself still had no idea; that realisation comes with the moment of the kiss, where a consonance (a major triad) appears as dissonance. Compositional virtuosity on Wagner’s part, of course, to show a world inverted, and potently stated here. 

Orchestral balancing was superb throughout, as was the balance between orchestra and the simply superb Glyndebourne Chorus (congregation!) in the outer acts, A pity, though, the bells were not more pronounced. Ticciati hears the power in Wagner’s quieter scorings, and finds a tissue delicacy riven with tension, with vast potential energy. And counterpoining of strands was enlightening (the angular strings against majestic brass in the Transformation Music); in many ways, and however confused they might be by the staging, lucky the person who heard the score of Parsifal for the first time on this particular afternoon. 

The casting was fascinating. One of the greatest Gunemanzes of all, John Tomlinson, sang Titiurel; and there was an almighty discovery in the Kundry of mezzo Krisina Stanek.  

The fearsome role of Kundry needs a very special type of singer, one with huge range and dramatic stamina. Singing Second Norn Götterdämmung at Staatsoper unter den Linden, Berlin in October this year night be a bit of. come down for Stanek from this. She has it all: the near-two octave downward leap as she describes laughing at Christ on the Cross was both soul-chilling and accurate; her caressing of line in the so-called ‘Herzeleide Narrative’ was more seductive than any of her stage actions.  She only sings oe word in act three (albeit twice), and how she made it count: ‘Dienen’ (to serve).

Parsifal himself was sung by Daniel Johansson, whose repertoire is certainly that of a Heldentenor. And yet, that steely edge and feeling of an eternally unflagging voice is not quite there; he filled the relatively small house well, though. John Relyea did make Gurnemanz his own, his narrations were nuanced, his diction fine, his attention to detail (and it is precisely that which makes those narrations) excellent. 

Audun Iversen was a convincingly-wounded Amfortas (we see the blood though a night shirt), triumphing vocally and conveying his character’s intense pain, both physical and spiritual, intensely; but it was John Tomlinson’s dramatic laser focus that really hypnotised. The voice might not be what we remember from his glory days, but Titurel is a role that Tomlinson now totally inhabits (he was Titurel for the Tcherniakov Parsifal under Barenboim in Berlin in 2021). This went a long way to complementing memories of Tomlinson’s own Gurnemanz at English National Opera in 2011- a role he has of course also taken to Bayreuth. Yes ,the voice’s lustre has gone, but it is after all an old man’s part, and Tomlinson delivered with blistering dramatic strength. It was a privilege to experience. 

Which, of the major roles, leaves Klingsor. The staging’s integration of the character into other, unfamiliar ‘zones’ of the opera enables a deeper layering to occur. Ryan Speedo Green exudes huge character, his invoking/awakening of Kundry in Act 2 imperious, sovereign. 

All of the smaller roles were well taken; perhaps a special word of praise should go to Ekaterina Chayka-Rubinstein’s Voice from Above. But the whole, vocally and orchestrally, was certainly greater than the sum of its parts; an expansion counteracting and complementing the production’s shrinkage of Wagner’s vision, though. 

Glyndebourne’s first Parsifal, whatever one’s reservations, remains a mightily impressive achievement.

Colin Clarke 

All photos © Glyndebourne Productions Ltd. Photo: Richard Hubert Smith