When I landed in Rome for the election of the 267th pope, I wasn’t consciously planning to recreate scenes from Conclave (2024)—despite being a big fan of Edward Berger’s ecclesiastical hit. And yet, barely a day after touching down at Fiumicino, there I was: by pure chance hurrying through the exact same noisy road/pedestrian tunnel where we encounter Ralph Fiennes’ Cardinal Lawrence in the picture’s opening moments.

I was halfway through the tunnel (part of the Via di Porta Cavalleggeri) when another accidental Conclave echo dawned: the friend-of-a-friend I was late for meeting outside the Vatican press building on Via della Conciliazione was a writer named Robert Harris. Not the author upon whose 2016 best-seller Peter Straughan’s Oscar-winning screenplay was based; rather an Australian journalist, byline Rob Harris. An amusing coincidence. But where the conclave is concerned, such things can easily seem a matter of eerily cosmic/theological significance…

While I’ve never been Catholic or indeed religious—very much the opposite, in fact—I’ve always found it very hard to resist superstition. As that notable Catholic convert Graham Greene wrote in his early novel It’s A Battlefield, “One had to choose certain superstitions by which to live; they were the nails in the shoes with which one gripped the rock.”

Superstitiousness is endemic among regular gamblers, I’ve found. I started betting (with my own money) in early childhood in the mid-70s, the wagers placed by my dad pretty much every Saturday. Back then I concentrated exclusively on horse-racing. But the major British bookmakers have long offered advance odds (“ante-post”) on myriad non-sporting events, from the Oscars to Eurovision to the identity of the next pontiff. Over the decades I’ve dabbled in many of them, with predictably variable results. But, I like to believe, overall a long-term profit thanks to “coups” such as Sandra Bullock for Best Actress in The Blind Side (still both my biggest bet and my biggest win.)

I date my interest in Vatican shenanigans to 1978, the Year of the Three Popes, whose August and October conclaves elected Albino Luciani and Karol Wojtyła as John Pauls I and II. I clearly remember, aged seven, precociously telling my mam in our Sunderland kitchen that the pope (Luciani) had died. She reprimanded me for bringing outdated news, presuming I meant the death of Paul VI a month before.

No, I insisted, I meant that the new one, the “smiling pope.” John Paul I’s reign had lasted just 33 days, the decidedly dodgy circumstances of its conclusion explored/explained by non-fiction books such as David Yallop’s persuasive page-turner In God’s Name, and also more facetiously by Salford post-punk legends The Fall—my favourite band—via their 1986 musical play Hey! Luciani: The Life and Codex of John Paul I. Lyricist/singer Mark E Smith left little room for doubt: “then one day the Curia murdered you…” he sneered on the coruscating single Hey! Luciani, which peaked at #59 on the British chart.

Luciani’s shocking “natural causes” (sic) demise was a massive deal at the time, almost as big as the death of Elvis Presley the previous summer. I credit the excitement generated by the October ’78 election and its stunning result—Poland’s John Paul II becoming the first non-Italian pope for centuries!—with sparking my interest in the conclave, which would steadily grow over John Paul II’s long reign. I recall being asked during a romantic Italian-restaurant dinner on Sunderland’s sea-front in 1999 about my ideal holiday-destination and replying “Rome, during the conclave.”

Four years later, with John Paul II rapidly ailing and succession-speculation mounting, I published the “Popewatch,” a webpage listing my idea of the leading candidates. This comprised a top 3—known in Vaticanology circles as a “Terna”—followed by another 14 possibles. I updated the page semi-regularly intervals over the next 22 years as cardinals were appointed (in “consistories”), died, or turned 80—the age when they are excluded from the conclave and thus effectively drop out of the papal running.

My impetus in monitoring the most “papabile” cardinals was, I’ll admit, largely gambling-related. Here was that rare betting-market where a dedicated individual could plausibly gain a real edge over the bookies. The catch being, of course, that chances to capitalise on this knowledge were often decades apart….


In 2005, the 26-year papacy of John Paul II finally came to an end and the bookies reported brisk interest in the papacy markets. The odds offered for obvious front-runner Joseph Ratzinger— who would be duly elected as Benedict XVI—seemed off-puttingly short, so I concentrated on outsiders; I’m generally drawn to long-shots, whatever the event. But I was forced to observe proceedings from afar via TV, as the conclave dates inconveniently clashed with UK work-commitments.

In 2013 we had the unusual situation of a papal abdication—its consequences detailed in Fernando Meirelles’ entertainingly lightweight The Two Popes (2019). By this stage the Popewatch—more respectfully christened the ‘Vatican Lounge’—had been online for a decade. My money this time went on Brazil’s Odilo Scherer (who I backed at 66/1 and 50/1 and who ended up around 3/1), Boston’s Sean O’Malley and Argentina’s Leonardo Sandri. The latter’s fellow Italian-Argentinian José Maria Bergoglio (a 20/1-shot) prevailed, taking the name Francis; this time I was stuck even further away, in California, watching via the internet.

My ambition of being in Rome for the big vote remained, and was only sharpened by Berger’s Conclave—which I saw and loved in a press/public screening at Spain’s biggest film-festival, San Sebastian, last September. I reviewed it very favourably from there for Sight and Sound magazine (“an engrossing ecclesiastical hoot which elegantly compresses a prestige-miniseries’ worth of meaty intrigue and lively incident into two brisk hours.”). The editor who commissioned me actually had no idea about my long-term Vatican bent. Another fishy “coincidence.”

Following the death of Francis on Easter Monday the chance of my being present in Rome and the Vatican for the conclave finally materialised. On 28th April it was announced that voting would begin on 7th May, which fitted nicely with my travel/work schedules—I quickly scrambled to track down transport and accommodation options. The spare room of my central-Rome-based pals wasn’t in a suitable state for guests, and staying in a city hotel was, I soon realiseds, beyond my budget. But after looking further afield I found the San Michele, a well-reviewed spot in the obscure suburban town of Aprilia—just half-an-hour away by train from Rome’s Termini station and just €50 a night b&b.

And of course I now needed to update the Vatican Lounge several times a day—under with the headline “After Francis: the papal contenders.” My two top fancies were both Italian: the charismatic Patriarch of Jerusalem, Pierbattista Pizzaballa, and super-liberal, Rome-based Matteo Zuppi, a popular pick at around 8/1. Pizzaballa was 16/1 on the day Francis died—which happened to be Pizzaballa’s (60th) birthday and also the city of Rome’s—but he found plentiful support and would wind up around half those odds.

In updating the Vatican Lounge I kept a close eye on news reports, journalistic predictions and social-media speculation, including an intriguingly specific Twitter account named @PopePredictor. This person behind this has devised a complex algorithm based on the outcomes of previous conclaves, and publishes an “index” for each contender on the first of every month. The lower the number, the more “papabile” the cardinal. It all looks very scientific, but the names at the top of their list have seldom tallied with those on the Vatican Lounge or indeed any other reputable website.

I glanced at the index occasionally in 2024 and early 2025 but didn’t accord it much credibility. My skepticism turned to incredulity on 1st March when a highly obscure American named Robert Prevost suddenly leaped out of nowhere to top the algorithm—and by a dazzlingly wide margin. I immediately engaged PP publicly on Twitter:
NY: Prevost is SO far ahead of the rest?
PP: Yes, he’s currently well ahead. That jump is due to his recent promotion to Cardinal Bishop.
NY: with respect I think this indicates that something’s seriously amiss with your algorithm. In a field of 130+, it seems obvious to me that nobody should be so far ahead, especially somebody who hasn’t been in *any* reputable rundowns of papabile, and is essentially an unknown.
PP: It very well could be amiss.
NY: Red flag, I think.
PP: It very well could be. I reserve the right to be wrong and completely embarrassed by the next Conclave.

While initially unconvinced, I did dig more deeply into Prevost’s papability and over the following weeks edged him slowly up my list. PP conversely (perhaps partly as a result of my oar-sticking) tweaked his algorithm, which then relegated Prevost to fourth. His name was absent from the bookies’ odds altogether until as late as 23rd April, when the American with joint Peruvian citizenship was quoted at a fairly dismissive 40/1 by a few firms. If his nationality didn’t count against him—the Italian press dubbed him “il meno americano tra gli americani,” or “the least American of the Americans”—the Chicagoan was definitely a plausible contender.

On 1st May he was veteran Vaticanologist John L Allen Jr’s “Papabile of the Day” on the invaluable website Crux (which he edits, “Taking the Catholic Pulse.”) Allen wrote: “there are three qualities cardinals look for every time they have to kick the tires on a possible pope: They want a missionary, someone who can put a positive face on the faith; a statesman, someone who can stand on the global stage with the Donald Trumps, Vladimir Putins and Xi Jinpings of the world and hold his own; and a governor, someone who can take control of the Vatican and make the trains run on time, including dealing with its financial crisis. There’s a solid argument Prevost ticks all three boxes.”

On the morning of Monday 5th May—the eve of my trip to Rome—he had reached #6 on my list, though the various bookies still had him as an outsider at 40/1 and 50/1. I wrote on Twitter that day: “The one who I sense rising stealthily and steadily upwards right now: Prevost.” That night he had actually entered my Terna in the third slot behind Pizzaballa (still my clear #1) and Zuppi. Early on the Tuesday morning at Vienna airport, waiting for my 8am flight to Rome, I emailed a conclave-engaged, Vienna-based Italian friend: “My shortlist of 3… is Pizzaballa, Zuppi and the American/Peruvian Prevost, who has been stealthily rising into contention in the last few days.”

Minutes later the Ryanair aeroplane’s wheels went up—and I was on my way to the city of Conclave, Sorrentino’s The Great Beauty, Argento’s Tenebrae, Fellini’s La Dolce Vita, Pasolini’s Mamma Roma, Rossellini’s Rome Open City, Minnelli’s Two Weeks in Another Town, Wyler’s Roman Holiday. And, ah yes, The Omen…