Photo © The Royal Opera | Johan Persson
RBO / Maria Jacquot
A revival of David McVicar’s time-honoured production of Mozart’ s Die Zauberflöte always brings up the old chestnut of just how does one tackle this most elusive of operas? Is it a fairy tale? It works, but only on a very superficial level if one treats it as such; or is it a Masonic parable, complete with composed initiation into the world of the Great Architect?
In a very real sense, it is both: the surface sense of fantasy masks the deeper lessons within, making it congruent with the deeper aspects of Freemasonry. Mozart was, famously, a Mason; interestingly, Nicholas Till”s RBO booklet essay Freemasonry and the Enlightenment touches on the relationship between Rosicrucianism and Freemasonry (the two were closer in Mozart’s day than in the former’s current-day incarnation as AMORC). And Rosicrucianism, like Zauberflöte, is famously allied with Ancient Egypt, to the extent that their start point (like, for example. 1 AD) is dated from, not Jesus, but from Amenhotep IV (Akhnaten): thus making consensus-2025 AD the Rosicrucian year 3374. Exploding out from that, Tamino’s rituals speak across most if not all mystical/initiatory orders, from the OTO (Ordo Templi Orientis) to the Golden Dawn. Further reading, should one be interested, exists in two notable directions: Till’s own brilliant Mozart and the Enlightenment (Faber and Faber, 1992), ad Frances Yates; The Rosicrucian Enlightenment (Routledge,1972).
So, balance is important. The staging, thanks to phenomenal sets by John Macfarlane and equally impressive lighting by Paule Constable, is certainly evocative of the darker spaces of an initiatory order’s complex. The final rising of the sun (Ra?), too, is glorious. But the initiations themselves are rather subdued, almost sidelined; Tamino’s acceptance is therefore somewhat diminished. There are definite positives on his journey, though, not least the phenomenal scenes between Papageno and Tamino
There are beautiful things along the way, for sure, not least the Phileas-Fogg-like flying bicycle for the Three Boys (magnificently sung). It is an almost-but-not-quite staging, but then again, Mozart does ask the near-impossible. Fairy tale, myth, fable: all speak to a collective unconscious that is not just of childhood.
But we do feel Tamino’s inner journey; we do feel sorry for poor old Papageno, then rejoice when Papagena is revealed as Papageno’s sweetheart, and is not the (disguised) old woman, after all. Stagings in which this is all a fantasy or dream have their place but consistently do not penetrate deeply enough (whatever the charms of, for example, Cécile Rousset and Julien Lubek’s Versailles staging (sung in French: Hervé Niquet conducts on the Château de Versailles Spectacles CD/DVD/Bluray box of the event). And, in the darkness of much of McVicar’s staging (maintained brilliantly via Revival Director, Ruth Knight), we do feel the journey of the soul available to Tamino, and palpably. Interestingly , the crescent moon for the Queen of the Night is more blinding than that of Sarastro’s final, sun-drenched glow: a warning, perhaps, that all I not what it seems?
It goes without saying that the conductor’s decisions need to be in congruence with both score and staging. Over the years, Maxim Emelyanychev (2022), Leo Hussein (2019) and Julia Jones (2013 and 2017) have formed part of this reviewer’s experience, none have really shone (perhaps surprisingly in Emelyanychev’s case) but none have quite lost the tension like the present incumbent, Marie Jacquot; the tempos brought back uncomfortable memories – if not quite so extreme – of Hartmut Haenchen’s superhumanly distended 2019 Don Giovanni at this house. Jacquot’s tempi seemed, much of the time, just under the minimum momentum required, which led to moments, if not of stasis, certainly of lack of direction.
It was good, though, to hear singers encouraged o vocal embellishments, which at least sounded somewhat off-the-cuff. And this was generally a fine cast. Perhaps we should start with the Papageno, Huw Montague Rendall, presumably sill flushed with success form his Gramophone Award for his album Contemplation (which includes arias from Zauberflöte). It is easy to hear why he won: his voice is burnished and beautiful, and yet he placed it entirely within Mozart’s world. He has stage presence, too: the “suicide” and his reticence around he event was brilliantly done. He works beautifully with other cast members, too, be it Pamina or Papagena. Solo numbers were uniformly well negotiated, from a lusty bird-catcher aria to ‘Wie stark ist nicht dein Zauberton”.
Good, then, that he was paired with one of the finest Paminas I have heard: Lucy Crowe, so perfect in her purity of sound (and, indeed, of demeanour) that every move and phrase was believable. Perhaps “Ach ich fühl’s” was her highpoint, and arguably the zenith of the evening. It is highest praise that only Sandrine Piau’s Pamina for Christopher Rousset at Gstaad in late September 2022 eclipsed Crowe.
Perhaps associated with later repertoire (his award-wining solo disc, Nessun Dorma, includes no Mozart), Amitai Pati gave a convincing, and Mozartian, Tamino, convincing in his “Dies Bildnis ist bezaubernd schön”.
In an interesting experiment, the booklet interviews both Queens of the Night in this run: the one we had (Kathryn Lewek) and Annie Fassea. Lewek, who began her career as a mezzo, has taken her Königin globally. It shows: she is very much the incarnation of power. Her act one aria, “O zittre nicht,” was superb, showed the singer in total control, the opening Larghetto perfectly judged, the Allego moderato thereafter a masterclass in agility (runs negotiated impeccably) and projection (the lower notes did come through), less secure, but only marginally, was her second act “Der Hölle Rache”.
Solomon Howard was the Sarastro; his voice is large and felt too much so here; his Ramfis in Aida for this house in 2022 felt a far happier assumption.
Both Gerhard Siegel as Monostatos and Marianna Hovhannisyan made much of the comedic elements of their roles as well as the more serious sides. Hovhannisyan is a Jette Parker Artist; and this bodes very well for her future, not least in how well she interacted (vocally and dramatically) with her Papageno. It was perhaps luxury casing to have Matthew Rose as Speaker of the Temple; Rose just oozes stage presence. The two “trios” (Ladies and Boys, the latter here listed as “children”) were finely balanced, Hannah Edmunds, Ellen Pearson and Emma Caringtona as the Ladies). Stuart Jackson and Graeme Broadbent were stalwart Men in Armour.
Vocally, this Zauberflöte was impressive, with Lucy Crowe and Huw Montague Rendall as the stand-outs; and the production, despite the above caveats, certainly has its merits. But the score needs more life; conductor Finnegan Downie Dear takes over for performances from October 28.
