Peter Mycroft, LSO, Sir Simon Rattle performing Gerhard’s Collages Photo (c) Mark Allan

Lucy Crowe, soprano; Peter Mycroft, tape electronics; London Symphony Orchestra / Sir Simon Rattle

Barbican Concert Hall, London, May 21, 2026

“A gamble, a real adventure into the unknown” was how Roberto Gerhard (1896-1970) described his Third Symphony, Collages, and I suspect that for many in the audience this revisiting of a key atonal piece from 1960, with its prominent tape-electronic component, was also something of a gamble. But for all that the majority of what was a very full house were there to hear Rattle conduct two of the most approachable works by Mahler and Strauss, a goodly number were also there to hear this rare outing for Gerhard’s coruscating score (which Rattle and the LSO will tour to Bristol, Paris, and Luxembourg to 1st June), a most encouraging thought.

The spark of inspiration for Gerhard was his witnessing sunrise in a plane over Ireland in the late 1950s. “Like the blast of 10,000 trumpets”, he later wrote, though 3 sufficed for the symphony’s iconic opening salvo, answered immediately by the electronic component (originally for magnetic tape) than runs like a skein through the composition. The balance between these acoustic and electronic elements—the ‘collages’ of the subtitle—was vividly realised on the night by Peter Mycroft, climaxing in what amounts to a magnetic (in every sense) cadenza towards the close. True, the electronic sounds themselves, collated by the composer from diverse sources and then mixed in the BBC Radiophonic Workshop, do sound of their time—not unlike the special effects of a 1950s sci-fi film—but it is what Gerhard does with them in context that is far more important: “the sound must make the sense” he once stated, and Collages undeniably makes sense. The warm, almost rapturous reception for the symphony, splendidly played by the LSO and paced by Rattle to the climax with its resounding chords and percussion commentary, was certain testament to its power.

An even more rapturous reception, however, greeted the close of Strauss’ Four Last Songs (1947-8), a perennial favourite arguably more of a “breathtaking” (to quote annotator Stephen Johnson) stylistic anachronism in 1948 than Gerhard’s electronics now. When sung so radiantly by Lucy Crowe, however (the songs, not the electronics), that should come as no surprise. If I am being picky, perhaps Crowe was solid rather in the opening Frühling, but her marvellous sense came to the fore in September, still more in Beim Schlafengehen, with its evocative solos for horn (Timothy Jones) and leader Benjamin Gilmore. Im Abendrot, with its trilling, valedictory larks, was gorgeous. In a sense, the Four Last Songs achieve their fullest impact only after the last notes have sounded, in the warm afterglow of what has proceeded. But then afterglow is the emotional core of these songs, of the composer’s long creative life, the Germany in ruins after the horrors of the War, of a wider culture seemingly destroyed.

Lucy Crowe, LSO, Sir Simon Rattle, Photo (c) Mark Allan

Lucy Crowe sings Strauss, LSO, Sir Simon Rattle Photo (c) Mark Allan

That culture was still alive, if perhaps over-ripe, at the close of the nineteenth century when Mahler composed his Fourth Symphony. I had long regarded it as one of the least interesting in Mahler’s canon, an anomaly between the more outwardly dramatic Third and Fifth Symphonies, until hearing the revelatory recording by Kenneth Woods from Colorado’s Mahlerfest a year or two ago. I was keen to hear how a live performance in other hands would fare and Rattle did not disappoint. Taking the opening movement at a decidedly quicker pace than the composer’s Bedächtig. Nicht eilen (‘Deliberate. Not hurried’) to great effect, he exposed the “Hades full of horrors” Mahler once linked the music to with greater elan than most. It had the feel of a scherzo in its fleet-footed sections, and there was plenty of impulsion in the second movement and—slightly more sedately—ensuing Ruhevoll, too. Lucy Crowe’s return to the stage (bedecked in vibrant green rather than the white she wore for Strauss) at Ruhevoll’s climax was a touch distracting—ambling on mid-movement would not be tolerated for orchestral players—but one could not fault the lovely singing that ensued. Added to the ravishingly beautiful playing of the LSO, one could not help feeling that this is how Mahler should be performed.