Love at first song: Deepa Johnny, Aaron Godfrey Mayes, ENO’s Cinderella (La Cenerentola) 2025 © Mark Douet-X4

ENO / Yi-Chen Lin
The Coliseum, London, September 27, 2025

Despite its faults, La Cenerentola does make an enjoyable evening in the theatre. Opera and libretto were both composed at white-hot speed across Christmas 1816 and into the New Year, in an atmosphere of creative tension that did not compromise the frothy, ebullient comic opera premiered at the Teatro Valle in Rome on 25th January 1817. Not for the first time, Rossini repurposed earlier music (such as the overture, from La gazzetta) and farmed out some minor vocal numbers to a colleague.

Based (very) loosely on Perrault’s classic version, Jacopo Ferretti’s storyline (in Cristopher Cowell’s new translation) differs from popular modern versions with an evil stepfather (the morally bankrupt Don Magnifico, played for all its comic worth by Simon Bailey, at times channelling his inner Simon Callow), two stepsisters ugly only in character and utter self-absorption (Isabelle Peters and Grace Durham), and a semi-magical fairy godfather in the scheming, purple-clad Alidoro, a nice turn from David Ireland, last seen as ENO’s Figaro getting wed last February. Absent also were the midnight curfew and, naked ankles not permitted on stage in 1817 Rome, glass slipper: crystal bracelets sufficed instead.

Isabelle Peters, Simon Bailey, Grace Durham, ENO’s Cinderella (La Cenerentola) 2025 © Mark Douet-X4

Two centuries on, Julia Burbach’s lively and colourful production, reset in present-day London rather than 1810s Salerno, nicely realigned these details with some delightful touches: mouse-masked children (as Alidoro’s hapless helpers) in a nod to Disney (one even bearing a pumpkin: redundantly, since an elevator provided transportation onstage between Cinderella’s home and the royal palace), the chorus of ancestral spirits in Harry Potter-like animated portraits, and much paying with ladies’ footwear in Act 1. More significant was the introduction of Cinderella’s mother as a silent, green-clad shade (walked and occasionally danced by Sarah Storer) to partner Alidoro. Endearing as all this was, allied to some terrific singing and a more active stage presentation than other, rather static productions I have seen, they could not deflect one from the opera’s major flaw: it is just too long for its material, a 90-minute opera buffa drawn out almost twice as long by needless asides, as in Don Magnifico’s revelation of his impecunity in the penultimate scene, and repetitions—Cinderella even sings as much (“Am I being repetitious? Am I being repetitious?…”) when first meeting the disguised Prince Ramiro in Act 1—too often applying the brakes as the evening progresses.

 

These caveats, though, lie at Ferretti’s and Rossini’s door rather than Burbach’s. Musically, the production had much to commend it, especially in the performance of ENO debutante Deepa Johnny in the coloratura title role, a model of luminous expressivity and the embodiment of ‘Goodness Triumphant’ (the opera’s subtitle, after all). Yi-Chen Lin conducted the ever-excellent ENO Orchestra with aplomb, taking the score at quite a lick: sometimes a little too much so for some of the ensemble scenes with their rapid-fire, almost G&S patter-song-like content. Diction and balance suffered at times with several singers struggling to make themselves heard in the welter of sound, making me wonder whether this theatre was just too big for this opera; the surtitles were a godsend. Aaron Godfrey-Mayes made a visually (though not vocally) unprepossessing Ramiro but the stand-out male role was Charles Rice’s louche Dandini, especially when disguised as the Prince. But the night belonged to Deepa Johnny and the wonderful ENO Chorus and Orchestra.

All Dressed-Up: ENO’s Chorus, Deepa Johnny, Charles Rice, La Cenerentola 2025 © Mark Douet-X4

La Cenerentola plays for a further five performances at The Coliseum on October 2, 4, 7, 9, and 14.