John Findon as Peter Grimes in Opera North’s production, conducted by Garry Walker, Photo credit: James Glossop (c) 2026

 

Peter Grimes is an opera of place above all things. We don’t need to question what holds the loner-fisherman Grimes on the bleak Suffolk coast – he tells us: “Familiar fields, marsh and sand, ordinary streets, prevailing winds”. The genius of Phyllida Lloyd’s 2006 staging is its genius loci. With the sparest of gestures and sets the director summons not the place but its essence: the salt-skin on every surface, the rot of seaweed in the damp air, the pervasive poverty, a community huddled together like a shoal and just as suspicious of any movement beyond their borders.

20 years on and Lloyd’s staging stings as keenly as it ever did. Anthony Ward’s set – a grey-blue seascape, melting sky into sea, deftly lit by Paule Constable – encloses the action on three sides, trapping the chorus in a crude, makeshift world of wooden pallets (that must supply pub, hut, church and Moot Hall) and a giant fishing net. Raised by a central pulley, it engulfs The Borough’s citizens in a strange embrace – blinding and binding them under its mesh, a totem of belonging. Once we’ve seen it, the opening tableau – Grimes’ naked body washed up wrapped in a net – takes on a more sinister significance.

It’s a suggestive, evocative 20th-century world, and if revival directors Karolina Sofulak and Tim Claydon don’t always find freedom within it (characters have a tendency to get moored on raft-like pallets, unable to interact naturally), there’s still a fierce charge to a staging that’s a fight for survival: submission or rejection; compliance or expulsion; Grimes or The Borough.

After stepping in to replace Gwyn Hughes Jones for English National Opera in 2023 and for a single performance at Dutch National Opera in 2024, it’s good to see young British tenor John Findon (winner of the 2025 Critics’ Circle Award for Emerging Male Artist) taking up the role in his own right. This is a voice already etched deep with character, finding both the fragile hope in “Now the Great Bear” and “In dream I’ve built myself some kindlier home” and the roaring, primal ferocity of his dealings with Borough gossips. Stamina is still building, as is the sense of his Grimes – a less sympathetic figure than Stuart Skelton’s man-child, softer than Jon Vickers’ hardened case. The relationship with schoolteacher Ellen Orford (Philippa Boyle) is more fully romantically realised here than often, upping the stakes on a tragedy already loaded with child-corpses.

Boyle’s wilfully fond Ellen dares makes this figure more ambiguous, less sympathetic – an enabler as well as a victim. Hounded and surrounded by the chorus, who turn the vicar’s investigation into a second quasi-trial scene with Ellen in the dock, she clings to her impossible hopes until the Embroidery Aria forces her to surrender them in real time. Vocally Boyle (making an assured role debut) keeps much of her delivery close to English song, leading with text and inflection rather than weight of sound, mindful of every eddy and surge in both text and line.

The supporting cast tend to the grotesque, even Simon Bailey’s Balstrode hard and matter-of-fact. Hilary Summers’ Auntie overflows with worldly back-story but lacks body in the middle of the voice, flanked by two unusually damaged, feral Nieces in Ava Dodd and Nazan Fikret. Johannes Moore has a devilish fascination as apothecary Ned Keene, and Claire Pascoe’s Mrs Sedley is a horror story waiting to happen.

Opera North music director Gary Walker is the helmsman, trying to hold a stage-filling Chorus and substantial orchestra on course through Britten’s squally score. There’s neither the power nor the unanimity of ENO or the Royal Opera’s recent accounts, but the music gains pace and urgency (despite two intervals) in the later acts, as citizens turn lynch-mob and orchestral seas dash and crash, stripping Grimes’ corpse and flinging it back to the town that created it.