The self-imposition of playing an entire Proms programme from memory produced the most astounding results when the Aurora Orchestra attempted this feat with Beethoven’s Choral Symphony in front of a crowd of five thousand in the summer. Playing ‘off by heart’ is not recommended by teachers as it smacks of parrot-like rote-learning and mechanical memory, but the tension generated in the Royal Albert Hall by this high-wire act without a safety net was released in an immediate standing ovation and delirious roars of approval from every quarter.

Conductor Nicholas Collon is the inspiration and genius behind this. He generated a current with his baton which the players felt through their body – standing up except for cellists, double-basses and the solitary tympanist Henry Baldwin who was the most courageous man on the stage, his every note an audible solo. The players’ intuition matched that of a shoal of fish, their ensemble telepathic. With no score to follow they fixed on the conductor or made beaming eye contact with each other, the pleasure evident, freed from the tyranny of the music stand.

Collon crouched for a pianissimo which was beautifully delicate but could have been more so. An oboe solo took a momentary wrong turn and a nervous horn smudged an entry but these human blemishes only intensified the experience. The funambulist’s wobble earned a gasp. The first movement slithered chromatically to a close, each echoed phrase ratcheting the spring more tightly. The scherzo danced with the swirling thrill of repeated rhythms, as released from counting bars, the players reacted to temporal proportion only and felt their entry according to the architecture of the whole and Collon’s summons of course. The adagio achieved a glowing legato. It is hardest of all to play from memory slowly as doubt may intrude in the long notes, but the players were foot-sure in their blindfold and no longer needed the paper intermediary between Beethoven’s mind and their shaping what was in it.

The composer has a wicked sense of humour. He includes a Turkish march with jangling janissary bells, bass drum, piccolo, bassoon. Collon choreographs them marching on from the wings, a comic rabble, unhampered by music stands. A moment to savour is the bassoonist’s flatulent low parp, bathos after the high-blown passion of the orchestra, although here the raspberry was obscured by an errant drum-beat. Well, what did you expect from musicians posing as a bunch of amateur Gastarbeiter?

The finale began. Where were the voices? They filtered on as the orchestra played, National Youth Choir, BBC Singers and four soloists. Bass Chris Purves mounted a podium and sonorously addressed the crowds like Liberty leading the people – not these tones! Sing of joy and brotherhood! The chorus responded, their young voices fresh and vital. lithe tenors high, brilliant, clear, heroic, sopranos with energy to spare. Having no copies, the singers used their hands in sign-language translation of Schiller’s words, a creative touch which the aurally challenged composer would have appreciated. The glittering expensive soloists mingled with the choir and orchestra – demonstrable égalité – as the entire ensemble hurtled towards its Bastille-storming conclusion and audience ecstasy.

Before the performance Collon had presented a half-hour staged introduction to the work with actors, musicians, and ‘signer’ to remind us of Beethoven’s affliction. Passages from the composer’s diaries gave a homely context – the problems with errant musicians, professionals recalcitrant, amateurs all too keen, his need for a haircut. Collon previewed the musical themes which perhaps detracted a little from their freshness when heard in context and we the audience rehearsed the Ode to Joy. That emotion was certainly generated by this most thrillingly memorable of Proms.

Rick Jones

Hon Gen Sec