Sakari Oramo holds aloft the score of Malcolm Arnold’s Fifth Symphony, photo (c) Mark Allan, BBC
Alexandra Dariescu, piano; BBC Singers & Symphony Orchestra / Sakari Oramo
Barbican Concert Hall, London, April 11th, 2025
I will make no bones about it, I was at this Barbican BBCSO concert for the Arnold Fifth Symphony (1961), which I have known and loved—on disc—for over fifty years but only ever seen live once before. It can be challenging to encounter a favourite work from a recording live in concert, but Sakari Oramo and the BBC Symphony Orchestra did not disappoint in a vibrant performance of a work chock-full of savage wit, gripping tension, sentiment and sentimentality (the composer unafraid to court Mahlerian banality as much as the inspired), soaring melody and scrunching dissonances, and the expression of grief, all decked out in scintillating orchestration.
It has long been a matter of puzzlement to me that Arnold’s colourful and emotionally powerful score, inspired by the premature deaths of four of his high-profile friends (clarinettist Frederick Thurston, horn player Dennis Brain, ballet choreographer David Paltenghi and—most tellingly—tuba player, cartoonist and raconteur Gerard Hoffnung), should have prompted such critical vituperation down the years, most famously after the premiere when an unnamed London critic wrote that the work was the product of “a creative personality in an advanced stage of disintegration.” Arnold’s rock-and-roll lifestyle did, indeed, catch up with him, but not in this score nor its predecessor, inspired by the Notting Hill Riots in 1958 which offended with its all-too-skilful incorporation of Caribbean music elements. Indeed, Arnold wrote ahead of the Fifth’s premiere: “After the first performance of my Fourth Symphony there were so many things I felt needed to be said musically that I am more than grateful for the opportunity given me by the Cheltenham Festival Society to attempt to say these things”, for which we are forever in his debt.
Oramo has history with the work, giving its long-overdue Proms premiere in 2021. His view of the work has deepened and his pacing throughout was astonishingly assured, welding the many disparate elements (that so annoyed early critics) into a logical whole. Yes, the score is volcanic, seething and broiling in the opening Tempestuoso especially, but Oramo showed how its various grief-stricken eruptions collapse back into the main flow, metamorphosing into new forms that are in turn ejected, reclaimed, and recycled. The BBC Symphony Orchestra did not put a foot wrong throughout, relishing the soaring lyrical lines in the Andante con moto (and Oramo kept the ‘con moto’ firmly in view) and especially the tricksy, quicksilver scherzo, Con fuoco, full of dark humour offset by music-hall-style banter. Oramo’s electrifying changes of pace paid dividends here and in the bizarre finale, Risoluto—Lento, where the fantastical opening march, played superbly by the orchestra, spirals down into bleak tragedy before the Andante’s big tune bursts back in one of British music’s most inspired moments, setting up the extraordinary coda, as if to say: “these men were extraordinary, and I loved them, but they are dead.”

BBC Singers & Symphony Orchestra, conductor Sakari Oramo; photo (c) Mark Allan, BBC
The concert had opened with the original 1938 version of Vaughan Williams’ ravishing Serenade to Music, setting the sixteen members of the BBC Singers at the front of the stage. It is said that Rakhmaninov, who had played his Second Concerto just before the Serenade’s premiere, was moved to tears sat in the audience afterwards, and I fancy he might well have been again by the lyrical fire that chorus, orchestra, and conductor brought to the score. What he might have made of Doreen Carwithen’s fine Piano Concerto (1946-8) is anyone’s guess—it was begun three years after his death—but I think he would have appreciated its fine lyrical flow, formal acuity and youthful elan: she was just 26 when it was complete. For most composers it would have marked a significant compositional debut—even if that did not take place until 1952, when she was 30—but she had already scored a public triumph with the premiere in 1947 of her overture, ODTAA (‘One Damned Thing After Another’, based on John Masefield).

Alexandra Dariescu performing Carwithen’s Piano Concerto; photo (c) Mark Allan, BBC
What exposure Alexandra Dariescu, newly appointed Professor of Piano at the Guildhall School of Music and Drama, has had to Carwithen’s music is unclear but she gave a fiery and ebullient account of it, wonderfully supported by Oramo and the strings of the BBC Symphony Orchestra. At home in the pyrotechnics in the swifter outer movements (Allegro assai and Moderato e deciso ma con moto), Dariescu’s finest playing came in the rapt central Lento, which annotator Leah Broad aptly described in the programme as the concerto’s “jewel”. Enthusiastically received on the night, one hopes this will encourage others to explore Carwithen’s music, but the laurels belonged to the orchestra and the performance of the Symphony.
The concert will be broadcast on Radio 3 on Tuesday, April 22nd, and will be available via BBC Sounds for 30 days thereafter.
