Those who love Puccini’s Tosca regard its dismissal as ‘a shabby little shocker’ as a badge of honour: they revel in the opera’s plot and passion. At the Royal Opera House, a new production directed by Oliver Mears replaces Jonathan Kent’s traditional interpretation, which has filled houses regularly since 2006. That production was neither shabby nor shocking, tending in the elegance of its direction and design towards the poetic. But it is the dramatic that Mears favours in his unflinching reading.

We are in an anonymous mid-20th-century war-torn western city ruled by an occupying force, but there is confusion. Who is shelling a city that has already been taken? Why are the faithful worshipping in a bombed-out apse with falling timbers, when the church is the people, who can move, not the building? Why are they genuflecting to an image of Mary Magdalen? Such noodling detracts from the undoubted sincerity of a production that writhes with the banality of evil – its seediness and casual cruelty.

Anna Netrebko as Tosca and Gerald Finley as Scarpia. Photo: The Royal Opera ©2025 Marc Brenner

The Royal Opera faced down criticism for engaging Russian soprano Anna Netrebko, her detractors believing that she should speak out in support of Ukraine. Demonstrators gathered outside the first night performance but did not disturb the performance. No wonder there was added tension in the air when Netrebko, seated, and defeated by her tormentor Baron Scarpia, plucked from the expectant air the first note of her more than usually apt aria ‘Vissi d’Arte‘ (‘I lived for art’).

Netrebko’s Tosca is the full package – glamorous in Ilona Karas’s La Dolce Vita gowns, both coquettish and determined, and every inch the diva she portrays. A luscious, chocolatey richness has bloomed in the lower register, complementing the famously golden top notes. Some wayward intonation on first night can surely be put down to the unusual external pressure. Could her Cavaradossi match this? Oh yes, Here was Freddie De Tommaso absolutely in his element, in the role that has defined his career, wherever else it goes. Mears makes him floppy-haired and boyish but increasingly brave as his political convictions are tested. When the enemy’s troops retreat his cry of ‘Vittoria!’ Vittoria!’ boasts a second ‘o’ that seems endless.

Love in ruins: Anna Netrebko as Tosca. Photo: The Royal Opera ©2025 Marc Brenner

As chief of police Scarpia, vicious ruler, religious hypocrite and lustful pursuer of Tosca, Gerald Finley is a slimy sleazeball, constantly fidgeting with his grubby handkerchief and trouser pockets, a truly revolting suitor. This is not the petrifying Scarpia of Puccini’s score, whose rising chords to herald him reflect his power more than his person. Finley’s naturally warm voice does not suit this heartless creep, but he can act repugnant, and no woman would want to be in a locked room with this Scarpia.

New production, political controversy and house debut as music director by Jakub Hruša – it was quite a night. Hruša’s tempi did not always shift in the same directions as those of the principals, but there is a case for a degree of wildness in this torrid story, and there were musical moments reminiscent of a film score as Hruša hurried political prisoner Angelotti (Ossian Huskinson) into hiding or hung back for dramatic effect. Certainly he ‘gets’ Puccini, and who can resist a little musical hurly-burly? From the Orchestra of the Royal Opera came some chilling solos. The Act One church choir drawn from the Royal Opera Chorus included, winningly if anachronistically, girls as well as boys.

Alessandro Corbelli as the Sacristan,and the Chorus of the Royal Opera. Photo: The Royal Opera ©2025 Marc Brenner

Alessandro Corbelli’s fussing Sacristan brought rare humour, Carlo Bosi’s Spoletta, Scarpia’s lackey, was a conflicted lickspittle, Olle Zeetterström impressed with his big-voiced, bureaucratic Gaoler, and treble Raphy Laming shone through the grim dawn of Act Three like a sunbeam.

In Simon Lima Holdsworth’s set design, after the blitzed church and austere marble void of Scarpia’s stolen palace, Act Three’s execution room comes as a jolt, with its blood-stained tiles and pointless paperwork. The death squad’s matter-of-fact killings are strong meat. Music that is beautiful to the end clashes awkwardly with stomach-churning ugliness, and that may not have audiences rushing back for more.

Tosca runs at the Royal Opera House, London, until 7 October. Main image: The Royal Opera ©2025 Marc Brenner