Christine Rice (Sister Helen Prejean, left) receiving the Best New Opera Production Award for Dead Man Walking from Amanda Holloway (Critics’ Circle), with (left to right) Bob Holland (executive producer), Lucy Nelson (producer). Photograph (c) Sophia Evans, 2026
The artists who impressed critics most in 2025 were presented with the Critics’ Circle Music Awards for that year in a ceremony at English National Opera on 7 October 2026. Musicians excelling early in their careers and impressive productions were celebrated, alongside one artist whose has thrilled generations of audiences, writes Claudia Pritchard, Critics’ Circle Music Section Chair.
Judging panels made up of critics from a broad range of publications celebrated Achievement in Opera with two awards: one to English National Opera‘s staging of Jake Heggie’s Dead Man Walking (best new production – see above), and one to Mark-Anthony Turnage’s Festen, named best new opera and staged by The Royal Opera. The awards were supported by Peter and Leslie MacLeod-Miller – Leslie made the presentation.

Hugo Pattinson (senior producer), Rebecca Nathan (producer), Richard Jones (director) receiving the Best New Opera Award for Festen from Leslie MacLeod-Miller. Photograph (c) Sophia Evans, 2026
Mezzo-soprano Beth Taylor and counter-tenor Hugh Cutting received their Rising Artist: Vocal awards from guest presenters mezzo-soprano Patricia Bardon and composer Bob Chilcott. Taylor was praised for her “fearless, magnetic presence to every role” and Cutting for his keenness to welcome challenges plus his ever developing skills as a stage artist”.

Mezzo soprano Beth Taylor receiving her award from Patricia Bardon. Photograph (c) Sophia Evans, 2026

Counter-tenor Hugh Cutting receiving his award from composer Bob Chilcott. Photograph (c) Sophia Evans, 2026
Junyan Chen, with her “breadth of musical curiosity”. was named the rising star among pianists, receiving her award from Critics’ Circle member and editor of The Pianist, Erica Worth. The Instrumental award was presented by Emma Baker, editor of monthly strings magazine The Strad, to French-born violinist Irène Duval. Judges admired “her musical intelligence, finesse and fearlessness”.

Pianist Junyan Chen receiving her award from Erica Worth. Photograph (c) Sophia Evans, 2026

Violinist Irène Duval receiving her award from Emma Baker. Photograph (c) Sophia Evans, 2026
Adam Hickox was named Rising Conductor of 2025, praised for his “chameleon quality, and an ability to let the repertoire speak without ego”. He received his award from Critics’ Circle member and former editor-in-chief of Opera Now, Ash Khandekar.

Conductor Adam Hickox receiving his award from Ash Khandekar. Photograph (c) Sophia Evans, 2026
For the first time, the award to Rising Composer was presented in memory of the critic Hans-Theodor Wohlfahrt, who died in 2025. His widow, Thérèse Cantine, presented the award to Lucy Walker, whose choral work reached audiences worldwide in the 2025 Proms while also being sung by small choirs up and down the land.

Composer Lucy Walker receives her award from critic Hans-Theodor Wohlfahrt’s widow, Thérèse Cantine. Photograph (c) Sophia Evans, 2026
In another first, the inaugural Early Music award, supported by Continuo Foundation, went to The Telling, whose innovative performances marry music of historical importance with present-day concerns. The foundation’s founder and CEO, Tina Vadaneaux, presented the award for Into the Melting Pot, praised as “a living means of communication through which audiences can reflect on exile, identity, resilience and belonging across the centuries”.

The Telling’s Clare Norburn receiving the Early Music Award from Continuo Foundation’s CEO, Tina Vadaneaux. Photograph (c) Sophia Evans, 2026
Pianist and musical ambassador Mitsuko Uchida, receiving the Lifetime Achievement award, while unable to attend the event in person sent a video message. IMG Artists’ Alexander Monsey accepted the award on her behalf from Music Chair Claudia Pritchard. Judges concluded their admiration for her work with a heartfelt “how lucky we have been that Uchida has made England her home for over half a century”.

Alex Monsey receives the Lifetime Achievement Award, from Claudia Pritchard, on behalf of Mitsuko Uchida. Photograph (c) Sophia Evans, 2026
Several artists performed to the invited audience during the presentation ceremony. The Telling, with soprano Heloïse Bernard and harpsichord player Aidan Phillips, performed Purcell’s “She Loves and She Confesses Too”. Hugh Cutting, with pianist Murray Hipkin, sang Vaughan Williams’s “Orpheus with his Lute”. With pianist Hamish Brown, Beth Taylor sang Herbert Howells’s “King David”, and Irène Duval played JS Bach’s Gavotte en Rondeau from Partita No 3. The evening concluded with Beth Taylor, Hugh Cutting, Irène Duval and Junyan Chen returning to the stage to give the first performance of an arrangement made especially for them by Lucy Walker of her popular song, “Make Me An Island”.

Irène Duval, Hugh Cutting, Beth Taylor and Junyan Chen performing Lucy Walker’s arrangement of Make Me An Island. Photograph (c) Sophia Evans, 2026
After the presentations, which were hosted by Claudia and Music Vice-Chair Jessica Duchen, the audience met and mingled over drinks and canapes – and talked about music…

Christine Rice, Beth Taylor and Jessica Duchen
celebrate. Photograph (c) Tom Eisner
