The young woman on the Tube, a dance student, was in no doubt. “It’s the best thing I’ve ever seen.” The opinion of someone a third of my age is something the producers of The Great Gatsby will value highly. The US musical, based on the novel by F Scott Fitzgerald has run at the Broadway Theatre in New York for over a year and is now staged with a mostly British cast at the London Coliseum. It may be set in the 1920s but it has its sights set firmly on an audience of the 2020s.
A generation raised on special effects and restless TikTok dance moves will love the skilful sets, a writhing knot of dancers and the come-uppance of a manipulative shark. This is the good news that English National Opera, owners of the Coliseum, need. A five-month run for The Great Gatsby underpins funding for the next opera season, to be announced in early May.

Jamie Muscato as Gatsby and Frances Mayli McCann as Daisy (c) Johan Persson
By then, the show will have bedded in, but it has hit the ground running, thanks in large part to the dancers who have individual personalities as well as breath-taking technique. Dominique Kelley’s no-holds-barred choreography moves this tangle of hedonistic characters as a single, writhing mass of delectable untrustworthiness.
Jason Howland’s music, played by a powerful 18-piece orchestra conducted by Chris Ma, supports this energetic spectacle. But the score itself is underwhelming. Up-tempo party numbers raise hopes, notably the opening “Roaring On” – “Where’s the party and can you take me there? And when that party’s over can you find another party somewhere?” But individual characters’ torch songs, largely in the key of loud, are pretty much interchangeable, building from confidential confessions to pained or triumphant climaxes. “For Her” might have a life as a wedding first-dance – as long as the bride is called Daisy.
Daisy is Daisy Buchanan, neighbour of mysteriously wealthy Gatsby, who entertains lavishly but dispassionately in Long Island. When new arrival Nick Carraway, her cousin, is talked into re-introducing her to old flame Gatsby, he brokers a nasty mess with deadly results.

Corbin Bleu, Rachel Tucker and Jon Robyns in The Great Gatsby (c) Johan Persson
Jamie Muscato, most recently Anatole in the Donmar Warehouse’s Natasha, Pierre & the Great Comet of 1812, plays bloodless Gatsby, with Frances Mayli McCann as Daisy. US artist Corbin Bleu makes his West End debut as Nick, with Amber Davies as aloof golfer Jordan Baker. John Owen-Jones is Gatsby’s brusque bootlegging partner in crime, Jon Robyns is faithless Tom Buchanan. Among the victims left by these wreckers are Joel Montague’s hapless George Wilson and Rachel Tucker’s desperate housewife Myrtle Wilson.
There is no improving on Fitzgerald at his best: “They were careless people, Tom and Daisy – they smashed up things and creatures and then retreated back into their money or their vast carelessness or whatever it was that kept them together, and let other people clean up the mess they had made.” With book by Kait Kerrigan and occasionally slick lyrics by Nathan Tysen, some of the essence of Fitzgerald comes through. Certainly the “careless people”. Not carless, though. The vehicles that cruise on and off the stage in toybox colours are the deadly playthings of the heedless.
Off-stage stars of the show are Linda Cho, whose opulent costume designs won a Tony on Broadway, and Paul Tate dePoo III, whose sets and video projections meld seamlessly into vistas as deep as the characters are shallow. The video game generation will be delighted.
English National Opera does not want for younger audiences itself, encouraging a new generation of opera-goers with free and reduced-price seats. Wouldn’t it be grand if, on the basis that “if you liked that, you will like this”, the young dancer on the Circle line, and thousands like her, had a crack at ENO’s repertoire too?
The Great Gatsby is at the London Coliseum until 7 September 2025
